Living In An Orwellian World

"[The fact that the court was willing to discuss the genocide charges was a] mark of shame that will not be erased for generations."

"We will continue to do what is necessary to defend our country and defend our people."

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu

Judges of the International Court of Justice are seen while ruling on a request by South Africa on behalf of Gaza on Friday. (Remko de Waal/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock)

The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide established in 1948 represented a determination to ensure that the crimes of the Holocaust would never be repeated. The crime of genocide requires proof of intentional destruction "in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group". When the Third Reich destroyed the lives of six million Jews in a deliberate, state-planned eradication of Europe's Jews, it was the very quintessence of genocide. The intent was there, the outcome spoke for itself. 

Israel saw its founding that same year of 1948. It exists today as a bulwark against another Holocaust. Finally, Jews had a reborn national territory of their own established on a small portion of their original ancestral land. And that nation developed a military for the obvious purpose of defending itself and Jews from another attempt at genocide. The International Court of Justice delivered its provisional response to South Africa's claim of genocide perpetrated by Israel on Gaza, on the very memorial date of the Holocaust.

Could anything be more spectacularly grim and ironic? Israel, by the metric of the court consenting to hear the case and adjudicate it well into years ahead before reaching a final decision even while failing to order Israel to retreat from Gaza, has been held in suspicion of genocide, marking it as the fifth country to face the charge of genocide in the ICJ. As in the United Nations itself, it is always the human-rights-abusing nations that hold Israel to account for violations of human rights. 

 

Israel's violation can be seen in the fact of its existence, in the indisputable fact that it exists only because it defends itself.

Sudan committed an intended genocide in Darfur. And when its president and the head of the Sudanese military were condemned by the ICC as war criminals the Organization of Islamic Cooperation and the Arab League paid no mind. Syria's Bashir al-Assad has been accused by the United Nations itself of having killed 300,000 of its own citizens. Today he is in good standing in the Arab League. Iran threatens genocide against Israel, has done so openly, former President Ahmadinejad openly declared at the UN General Assembly Iran's intention to destroy Israel.

Open displays of of rampant antisemitism and the celebration of the Hamas terrorist bloody rampage through southern Israel on October 7 have taken place in huge rallies throughout the Western world. A world that stands by and merely observes 'pro-Palestinian' calls in gatherings on city streets calling for another intifada, calling for a Palestine 'from the river to the sea', calling for 'gas the Jews'. These are akin to the rallies and the vicious propaganda that presaged the Holocaust.

How can any rational mind support a charge of genocide against Palestinians by Israel, when the populations of both Gaza and the West Bank have risen steadily at a rate not seen elsewhere in the world? Of a people considered by the United Nations to be refugees. Whose leaders gather huge sums of funding from the international community free to plunder and amass personal wealth. And for Hamas to build a network of offensive tunnels while amassing a huge cache of weaponry. 

 

The target is Israel. The intent is there, the attacks are deadly. 

In Israel, 20% of the population is comprised of Palestinians. They have citizenship, a quality of life denied Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza, while their leaders accumulate personal riches and deny proper administration of the territories that would allow the Palestinian people to prosper, have proper employment and live satisfying lives instead of being fed non-stop malicious lies about a neighbour hoping at some time to be able to relax its military vigilance.

Pro-Palestinian demonstrators gather outside the International Court of Justice in the Hague, the Netherlands, on January 26, 2024.

Nikos Oikonomou/Anadolu via Getty Images