"I
believe you are mischaracterizing this work. As an academic of nearly
40 years, I see no evidence of plagiarism in the thesis you cited nor
any unusual academic practices."
"Mark's
thesis was evaluated and approved by a faculty committee that saw his
work for what it is; an impressive and thoroughly researched analysis
that set him apart from his peers."
Margaret Meyer, Official Fellow of Economics, Nuffield College, Oxford University
"Oxford's guidelines are not atypical from other universities."
"When
you have something lifted verbatim from a source, in there without
quotation marks or citation ... that constitutes plagiarism."
Oxford graduate professor
"He's just directly repeating without quotations. That's what we call plagiarism."
"[Some
of Liberal Leader Mark Carney's thesis questions might be considered by
some as more of a] grey area, [but it would still constitute plagiarism
according to Oxford standards."
"It seems like it's [examples of plagiarism] all over the dissertation."
Geoffrey Sigalet, assistant professor, member UBC president's advisory committee on student discipline
Perhaps
it would be more accurate to say that elite economist and now leader of
the Liberal Party of Canada, Mark Carney, who has taken on the
as-yet-unelected mantle of Canadian Prime Minister's 1995 doctoral
thesis in economics from Oxford University, titled 'The Dynamic
Advantage of Competition' is fairly well shot through with examples of
plagiarism, an absolute sin in academic circles, as it is in journalism
and other recorded-word disciplines. A total corruption of what is felt
to be authentic, original observations based on study and analysis.
According
to the learned judgement of three university academics there are ten
distinct instances of apparent plagiarism in that doctoral thesis. Full
quotes, paraphrases, or slightly modified quotes from four different
writers previously published were used by this aspiring economist
completely lacking acknowledgement or proper attribution. In the
investigation leading to an expose published just recently, Oxford
University administrators failed to respond to a request for comment.
His election adversary, Pierre Poilievre, leader of the Conservative Party of Canada, did respond by commenting on X:
Mark Carney loves to brag about his experience. Here it is:
- - Plagiarism
- - Tax evasion
- - Creative accounting
-
- Abusing tenants
- - Union busting
- - Moving his headquarters out of Canada to the U.S.
- - Denying insurance claims to coal miners dying of black lung
- - Taking massive loans from Chinese state-owned banks
- - Advisor to Justin Trudeau on the economy
Examples
abound of Mr. Carney's laissez-faire attitude toward straightforward
truth where he has been caught out on a number of occasions dissembling
and playing with verifiable facts in an effort to shield himself from
the responsibility incumbent on one who expects to be believed by a wide
segment of the population when he declares himself fit and prepared to
lead a nation. So perhaps it isn't quite surprising that his lax
demeanor reflecting a propensity to lift other peoples' ideas and
present them as his own has become habitual with the man.
There
is the direct example of his lifting and adopting ideas and promises
made by the Leader of the Official Opposition in Parliament during the
current federal election campaign. Barely changing the wording of
campaign pledges originating with Pierre Poilievre, to present them as
his very own inspirations to better the lives of Canadians. Making other
statements to appeal to the electorate that clearly belie his
oft-stated beliefs and priorities which clash directly with those
statements geared to impress voters in a positive manner.
In
Mr. Carney's thesis he refers extensively to a 1990 book by Michael
Porter, The Competitive Advantage of Nations, where he duplicated parts
of Porter's work, presenting sentences with minor tweaks, as his very
own brainchilds. Writing in his thesis virtually exactly what he had
taken out of Porter's book, adding "an" to a sentence and "even",
without quotation marks to alert the reader, without the addition of a
footnote to reference someone else's work being quoted.
All perfectly acceptable, according to his thesis supervisor at Oxford who stated that "it is typical that overlapping language appears" when sources are
"frequently referenced in an academic text. For example, over the
course of this more than 300-page thesis, the Michael Porter book ... is
cited dozens of times. Within his thesis, Mark acknowledged, cited,
scrutinized and expanded on this piece", she elaborated, noting that his PHD thesis is "twice as long" as her own. Statements that should raise some eyebrows.
In
some instances Mr. Carney duplicates another author's sentences using
minor alterations, replacing "for example", with "e.g.", or changing one
or a few words, for "be" to "become", or "likelihood" to "probability".
Proper citation was not added to indicate he had lifted an author's
words, nor were quotation marks added. Shifty practices which anyone who
considers themselves as highly intelligent as Carney does, would
acknowledge them to be.
 |
Canada is due to go to the polls on April 28 GETTY |
"[Plagiarism is regarded by Oxford University] as a serious matter."
"Cases
will be investigated and penalties may range from deduction of marks to
expulsion from the University, depending on the seriousness of the
occurrence."
"[Oxford
University defines plagiarism as [p]resenting work or ideas from
another source as your own ... by incorporating it into your work
without full acknowledgement."
Oxford University Website
 |
On its website, Oxford University says it regards plagiarism “as a serious matter.” Photo by Oli Scarff/Getty Images |