Dangerous Driving Causing Death
"I find on all the evidence at this trial that the Crown has proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr. Singh was driving in a manner that was dangerous to the public.""It was a sunny day, about -21 degrees Celsius at the time. The road was bare, it was wet, but it had been salted.""The horrific extent of the crash was well documented in photographs entered as exhibits at trial.""The Freightliner began to jackknife with the tractor rotating counter-clockwise and contacting the left side of the cab of the tractor with the left side of the trailer. The Freightliner travelled across the centre lines and entered into the eastbound lane.""It [Expedition] entered the eastbound shoulder of the highway in an attempt to avoid the Freightliner. At the point of impact the Freightliner was travelling 97 km/hr. The impact caused the Freightliner's front bumper to detach from the frame of the truck. The Expedition was crumpled on its left side from front to back."Justice F. Bruce Fitzpatrick, Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Thunder Bay Courthouse
"It was clear on the evidence that a transport trailer unit using all season tires, travelling downhill, on a clearly marked curved winter highway, travelling at least 30 kilometres above the recommended speed and 20 km/hr higher than the post speed, constituted a marked departure from the standard expected of a reasonably prudent commercial truck driver."Crown argument"[Police] failed to do critical mechanical tests on the Freightliner to verify if the components were functioning in a way that in turn could assist in assessing the veracity of the [truck's onboard computer.""Further, the police failed to do friction tests for the presence of ice in the area of the crash."Singh's lawyer
On a January morning in 2023, 24-year-old Gursharan Singh's tractor-trailer jack-knifed, crossed the centre line about 27 kilometres east of Terrace Bay, Ontario, colliding with another motorist. As a result of that collision, Arthur Meinen, 64, died of multiple injuries when his SUV was hit west of a bridge over the Steel River. Given the fact that Mr. Singh was driving over the speed limit, that driving conditions were reasonable for anyone assumed to be in control of a vehicle, Gursharan Singh has been convicted of dangerous driving causing death.
Mr. Singh was driving a loaded Freightliner, while Mr. Meinen was driving an SUV, his white Ford Expedition eastbound on Highway 17. His wife was present in the passenger seat, when her husband was killed on January 28, 2023. Mr. Singh's fully-loaded trailer was headed westbound on the highway. Two Ontario Provincial Police officers who responded at the scene testified. "They both gave opinions that speed was a factor in the cause of the collision", which left both vehicles severely damaged.
The Expedition's airbags deployed fully as a result of the impact. And while the injuries sustained by Mr. Meinen led to his death, his wife suffered only minor injuries. The Freightliner's driver, Gursharan Singh, was uninjured. Arthur Meinen had been driving his Expedition east, at about 88 km/hr. Video captured by the Freightliner's dash camera "clearly showed the collision", and was entered as evidence.
![]() |
| Source: TimminsToday / Local Journalism Initiative. |
"...At its highest, the Crown has only proved speeding on a bare road. It has not proved dangerous driving, and it has not proved a marked departure", observed Mr. Singh's lawyer. Justice Fitzpatrick, however, accepted the evidence as expert, from the attending police with respect to the speed that Mr. Singh's truck was travelling immediately prior to the fatal collision. He was also satisfied that the Feightliner's computer data "was reliable and accurate". He did not consider that a momentary lapse in safe driving had occurred in reflecting on Mr. Singh's actions behind the wheel. And on that basis found him guilty of dangerous driving causing death.
Perhaps the driving code should be considered for change. That men under a certain age might be considered too professionally immature to drive tractor trailers, given the number of those behemoths now travelling on every highway, and the number of accidents that occur. All too often driven by young men, young men of Indian extraction, many of whom have been relatively newly arrived in the country, many of whom have not undergone rigorous professional training to the extent required to safely drive such vehicles.
"In my view, Mr. Singh's driving was dangerous because he was taking a chance that the light traffic highway conditions and his success so far that day in keeping his truck under control, meant that his excessive speed would not cause anyone any problems."The Crown has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the Freightliner's speed was in excess of the legal limit in a range of 15 to 20 km/hr.""In my view, the Crown has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that driving this much over the limit for this amount of time, in conditions where it is possible for ice to form on bridges or on road surfaces, which conditions were marked by signage indicating a bump and a reduce speed caution in a downward curve, represents driving that is dangerous in all the circumstances and was a marked departure from the standard of care expected of a reasonable tractor trailer driver in the circumstances."Justice F. Bruce Fitzpatrick, November 9 decision, Thunder Bay Courthouse
Labels: Dangerous Driving, Deadly Collision, Winter Reasonable Driving Conditions

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home